#Lefties and righties: Asymmetry in fish genitalia

Evolutionary biologists from the University of Konstanz have resolved a century-old question regarding the asymmetric genitals of internally fertilizing fishes of the family Anablepidae. Surprisingly, the direction of genital asymmetry in these fishes is random rather than hereditary.

Four-eyed fishes of the genus Anableps and their relatives are a fish family from the neotropics with a number of bizarre traits that have fascinated naturalists for centuries. These include a “split” eye that allows them to see both above and under the water surface at the same time; being live-bearers, meaning that they give birth to fully developed offspring just like mammals; and conspicuously asymmetric genitalia among the males of all species and among the females of some species.

Asymmetric and polymorphic
The genitalia of the males, so-called gonopodia, are transformed anal fins that can be used as a copulatory organ to inseminate compatible females. Curiously, these penis-like structures are asymmetric and their tip is bent either to the left or to the right. Females in turn have an asymmetric overgrowth of tissue that covers the genital opening laterally. Consequently, only compatible males and females can successfully mate. Within populations, both righties and lefties exist. Strikingly, the question as to whether this asymmetry is heritable or random has remained unresolved for more than a century.
New research carried out by evolutionary biologists from the University of Konstanz in collaboration with the Fundación Miguel Lillo in Argentina and published in the Proceedings of the Royal Society B shows that the direction of genital asymmetry in anablepid fishes is not inherited but, in fact, determined randomly.
Why side matters
“We started out with a fairly simple question,” says Dr. Julián Torres-Dowdall, lead author on the study and a researcher in the University of Konstanzʼs Zoology and Evolutionary Biology laboratory led by Professor Axel Meyer: “Do left-sided males father mostly left-sided sons? This may appear to be a strange question to ask, but for evolutionary biologists, asymmetry in general, and the issue of heritability in particular, is incredibly interesting due to its potential to drive the emergence of new species.”

Anablepid fishes are especially interesting not only because their genitals are asymmetric—an uncommon trait they share with some insects, snakes, most ruminant mammals, waterfowl and certain fish families. Interestingly, individuals with left or right-sided genitalia can be found at similar proportions within populations. “This is rare and useful at the same time as it allows us to address the issue of heritability and, consequently, to understand the evolution and maintenance of both genital forms (lefties and righties) and its potential to differentiate populations and possibly speciation,” adds Torres-Dowdall.
Chance, not genetics
To determine whether sidedness of genitalia in anablepid fishes is determined genetically and passed down to the next generation, the researchers studied two genera of the Anablepidae family: Anableps, which comprises three species of four-eyed fish, and Jenynsia, a genus comprised of 15 species of one-sided live-bearers. Combining breeding experiments with genomic analyses, the team established that there is no strong heritability to the direction of genital asymmetry in anablepid fishes.
“Our experiments with both captive and natural populations showed that all offspring were asymmetric—with a near-equal proportion of left and right genitalia in the natural populations and in the breeding experiment,” says Torres-Dowdall. In both cases, the sons’ genital sidedness was independent from the father’s sidedness. “This strongly suggests that the direction of asymmetry is determined by chance rather than heredity and goes some way towards explaining the persistence of this peculiar trait over time.”
Incompatibility between morphs not a driver of speciation
The genomic analyses showed no evidence that genetic markers, i.e., specific regions of the genome, are associated with genital asymmetry. Furthermore, there was no evidence of accumulated genomic differences between left- and right-sided individuals. This conforms with the general pattern found in other species with similar asymmetric traits. Also, there is no suggestion that the existence of left and right-sided genitalia should be regarded as potential drivers of speciation: “There is the idea that incompatibility between left and right-sided individuals might potentially result in the evolution of two new asymmetric, yet either left or right-sided, species,” explains Torres-Dowdall. “However, for a new species to evolve, variation in the direction of asymmetry would have to have a genetic component. Our study strongly suggests that this is not the case with anablepid fishes.”