#Earnings Results: Netflix stands to shed nearly $45 billion in market cap after ‘borderline catastrophic’ forecast

The number allayed the stark warnings of some analysts, including JPMorgan’s Doug Anmuth, who had feared a significant shortfall of new subscribers, but executives do see a precipitous slowdown ahead — they predicted just 2.5 million net new subscribers in the first quarter, less than half the 5.8 million that analysts were projecting on average, according to FactSet.

Netflix shares plummeted nearly 20% in after-hours trading following the announcement Thursday, which would lop off nearly $45 billion in market capitalization from the streaming giant, which ended Thursday’s trading session worth more than $225 billion. The stock is down 12% over the past 12 months; the broader S&P 500 index 
SPX,
-1.10%
has improved 17% in the past year.

Netflix executives said that a lack of new original programming, especially early in the quarter, was a factor in their forecast. Netflix unloaded a wealth of new content in the holiday quarter, including new seasons of popular TV hits like “The Witcher” and “Emily in Paris” as well as some of the biggest movies the service has ever launched, like “Don’t Look Up” and “Red Notice,” and isn’t expecting big new releases until later in 2022.

“Our guidance reflects a more back-end weighted content slate in Q1’22 (for example, ‘Bridgerton’ S2 and our new original film ‘The Adam Project’ will both be launching in March),” they wrote in a letter to shareholders announcing the results. “In addition, while retention and engagement remain healthy, acquisition growth has not yet re-accelerated to pre-COVID levels. We think this may be due to several factors including the ongoing COVID overhang and macro-economic hardship in several parts of the world.”

Netflix’s subscriber growth has waned as the COVID-19 pandemic has marched on, and the streaming service added 18.2 million new subscribers total in 2021, fewer than it added in just the first six months of 2020, when the virus first spread across the globe and caused a wave of shelter-in-place restrictions.

See also: Some on Wall Street want Netflix to stop reporting subscriber growth

As subscriber growth has slowed, Netflix has looked to increase prices in mature markets to continue to grow revenue. After hiking prices in October 2020 for the U.S. and Canada, Netflix confirmed last week it is doing so again for that region, pushing the price of its basic plan higher than the cost of AT&T Inc.’s
T,
-0.95%
HBO Max streaming service.

Netflix’s recent subscription price increase signaled the top of the company’s domestic growth potential, with 74 million households in the U.S. and Canada, Berna Barshay, an analyst at Empire Financial Research, told MarketWatch.

“The subscription guide was borderline catastrophic, and they ran into the law of large numbers” with a stock price at a huge valuation, she added.

Netflix said its sales grew to $7.71 billion in the holiday quarter, up from $6.6 billion in the same period a year ago. Profit was expected to decline as a wave of premieres required Netflix to recognize the costs of expensive content such as the newest season of “The Witcher,” but the company reported earnings of $607 billion, or $1.33 a share, up from $1.19 a share a year ago. Analysts polled by FactSet expected earnings of 83 cents a share on sales of $7.71 billion.

Read: Here’s what’s coming to Netflix in February 2022 — along with a price hike

Netflix continues to command viewer loyalty worldwide — 70% of its desktop visitors watched it exclusively — despite a glut of competition from HBO, Apple Inc.
AAPL,
-1.03%,
Walt Disney Co.
DIS,
-1.66%,
Amazon.com Inc.
AMZN,
-2.96%,
Comcast Corp.
CMCSA,
-0.22%,
ViacomCBS Inc.
VIAC,
-3.82%
and others, based on figures from data intelligence platform Similarweb in December 2021. Similarweb noted that fewer consumers are canceling Netflix, based on a decline in cancellation rate.

Still, Netflix’s vice-like grip on the market has slipped the past two years as competition has escalated, according to one research firm. From the second quarter of 2020 to the fourth quarter of 2021, Apple TV+, Disney+ and HBO Max combined grew from 10.6% to 20.6% of global interest among consumers, while Netflix dropped from 55% to 45.4%, Julia Alexander, a senior analyst at Parrot Analytics, told MarketWatch. 

Netflix executives admitted in their letter to shareholders that competition was affecting growth, the first time they have made that admission in a regular quarterly update on the competition.

“While this added competition may be affecting our marginal growth some, we continue to grow in every country and region in which these new streaming alternatives have launched,” the executives wrote, later adding that “with under 10% of total TV screen time in the U.S., our biggest market, Netflix has tremendous room for growth if we can continue to improve our service.”