We’re already tallying your votes for the Best Shows of the ‘90s. But before we share those results, and before we reveal our very own impressive, definitive, and much sweated-over rankings, here’s what TV Guide Magazine thought were pretty good shows while we were actually living in the ’90s. That’s without the benefit of hindsight, or realizing we would, three decades later, become obsessed with the ’90s, and take our own nostalgic look back at the decade of O.J., Monica, Brad & Gwyneth, Ben & Gwyneth, and then, of course, early Brad and Jen.

TV Guide Magazine editors went through the entire decade of covers — over 500! — to choose 9 we thought were the best of the best, featuring series like Seinfeld, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, ER, and The X-Files. It looks like our choices back then have stood the test of time. Well, most of them.

We’ll see on July 11 when our 90s list begins to roll out. In no particular order, here are some awesome ’90s TVGM covers that are all that and a bag of chips.